Dmitry Dvornitsky

The server agent that cost $0.90 per reply

Making the wrong writer cheaper saved 90%. Choosing the right writer removed the step.

$0.90 per reply

The problem

An agent on the server answered replies to cold email. One run per reply: it read the project’s brief, the skills, the inbox and every reply in it, again on each turn.

30–40 turns, 1–1.7 million input tokens, $0.80–1.00 per answered reply. In October, reply runs were most of the agent’s $100+ a month. Most replies need none of that: a thank-you for a referral, a plain question the brief already answers.

Step one: one call instead of a run

A drafter: one model call per reply, with the brief, the rules, the campaign, the lead and the whole thread. One verdict:

  • draft: an answer waits for a person to approve in Slack;
  • none: nothing to answer;
  • agent: it needs free times, a booking or a fact to look up.

Unsubscribes, away notes, “no” and thank-yous were settled without a call. The instructions and the project were cache breakpoints. 15–30 thousand input tokens: $0.08–0.15, a tenth of a run.

Step two: nothing on the server writes

Eleven days later the drafter was gone. Every answer the server wrote read as generic, and the SDRs rewrote each one with their own Claude Code, which wrote it far better. It has their memory of the project, the client and how they write. A server run starts from nothing every time.

Now the server classifies and the person’s own Claude writes: a scheduled task in the Claude desktop app, every 15 minutes, reads the waiting replies and writes drafts. A person approves as before. The server agent’s token is refused on any write a lead will read.

The trade-off

Server run One call The person’s Claude
Cost per reply $0.80–1.00 $0.08–0.15 their subscription
What it knows the brief the brief and the thread their memory of the client
Wait a minute a minute up to 15 minutes, app open

The cost was the visible problem. Quality was the real one: the cheapest draft is still waste if a person rewrites it.

All decisions